Showing posts sorted by relevance for query heart attacks. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query heart attacks. Sort by date Show all posts

Friday, 16 October 2009

When the lie's so big


I think I'm starting to know how Bill Murray felt in Groundhog Day...

Bans on smoking in restaurants and bars reduces [sic] the risk of heart attacks among non smokers, according to [sic] hard hitting report.

The research, by the U.S. Institute of Medicine reviewed 11 key studies of smoking bans in Scotland, Italy, the U.S and Canada.

They [sic] found drops in the number of heart attacks across the board, ranging from six per cent to an impressive 47 per cent.

Since the idea of smoking bans dramatically reducing the heart attack rate is yet again being circulated by lazy (and illiterate) journalists, I don't feel so bad about publishing yet again the facts which show this to be complete and utter rhubarb. Not only has it not happened, but it could never happen. The smoking bans of England, Scotland and Wales had no effect whatsoever on Britain's heart attack rate. 

And no, before you ask, the figures shown below have not been peer-reviewed. There is no need to peer-review complete hospital admissions statistics. They represent the complete data set. They are painstakingly reviewed by professional statisticians before they are published. These statisticians have no agenda and no a priori hypothesis to support. These are the facts.

Epidemiological studies require peer-review because they use a sample of the population to make claims about the entire population. They could, and do, get it wrong. The hospital data of England, Scotland and Wales are the evidence for the entire population. Complaining that these statistics are not peer-reviewed is like MORI complaining about an election result because they failed to predict the result.

And, unlike Jill Pell, Stan Glantz and all the other authors of the heart attack miracles, I can show you the raw data behind the facts. They are here, here and here. 


The myth of the smoking ban ‘miracle’

‘Heart attacks plummet after smoking ban’ declared The Sunday Times earlier this month, as it reported that England’s smoking ban has ‘caused a fall in heart attack rates of about 10 per cent’ (1). A few days later, The Scotsman upped the ante, informing its readers that ‘Smoking ban slashes heart attacks by up to a third across world’ (2).

Tales of heart attacks being ‘slashed’ by smoking bans have appeared with such regularity in recent years that it is easy to forget that there is a conspicuous lack of reliable evidence to support them. It is almost as if the sheer number of column inches is a substitute for proof.

The most recent reports are a case in point. Although The Sunday Times claimed a 10 per cent drop in heart attacks, nowhere in the 500 word article was a source mentioned and no one was quoted giving this figure. The ‘study’ the newspaper referred to does not exist, and the anti-smoking pressure group Action on Smoking and Health (ASH) – not renowned for downplaying the risks of passive smoking – went to the unusual lengths of posting a notice on its website the following day to point out that ‘the figures reported in The Sunday Times yesterday (and now circulating elsewhere) are not based on any research conducted to date’ (3).

Although the story quickly went around the globe, no one seems to know where the figure came from. It’s all rather strange. Basing journalism on anonymous sources is commonplace in the world of politics, but it is surely not necessary in the realms of science.

The second story – reported by a host of news organisations, including the BBC – also had no new data to report. Instead, it took its cue from an article in the journal Circulation which examined previous smoking ban/heart attack studies. If nothing else, the Circulation paper offers an opportunity to reflect on just how feeble the collected evidence is on this issue (4).

The first study to make the claim that smoking bans ‘slash’ heart attacks was met with howls of derision when it was published in the British Medical Journal in 2004 (5). Studying the modest population of Helena, Montana – where the number of monthly heart attacks seldom strayed into double digits – the study’s authors made the astounding claim that the town’s smoking ban had led to the rate of acute myocardial infarction (heart attacks) plummeting by 40 per cent.

Dubbed the ‘Helena miracle’ by a legion of sceptics, the 40 per cent finding was damned by its very enormity. Since the authors were adamant that the drop was due to secondhand smoke (rather than smokers quitting), the finding required the reader to believe that 40 per cent of heart attacks in pre-ban Helena had been solely caused by passive smoking in bars and restaurants. To understand quite how miraculous the Helena miracle was, one must bear in mind that around 10 to 15 per cent of coronary heart disease cases are attributed to active smoking. That passive smoking could be responsible for a further 40 per cent strains all credibility.

Despite the inherent implausibility of the hypothesis, further studies were swiftly commissioned. If smoking bans could be shown to immediately save lives, it would be a compelling reason to implement bans elsewhere and expand those already in place. And since all that was required to ‘prove’ the hypothesis was a rough correlation between a declining heart attack rate and the start of a smoking ban, the prospects were good. Heart attack rates had been falling for years in most countries and there were plenty of smoking bans to choose from. The law of averages dictated that another heart miracle would soon come to light.

Flawed though it may have been, the Helena research was followed by several studies that displayed such a cavalier approach to the scientific process that they bordered on the comical. Researchers in Bowling Green, Ohio, for example, saw a large rise in heart attacks during the first year of the smoking ban. Side-stepping this awkward fact, they simply redefined year two of the ban as the ‘real’ post-ban period and, since that year followed an abnormal peak, there was naturally a decline in the heart attack rate. As a consequence, the researchers could triumphantly declare that the smoking ban had led to a 47 per cent reduction in heart attacks (6).

In the Piedmont region of Italy, there was an inconvenient rise in heart attacks amongst those over the age of 60 after the ban, and so those people were simply ignored. In a study that was trailed by the BBC (‘Smoking ban reduces heart risk’), the researchers focused entirely on those under 60, thereby recording an 11 per cent drop in cases (7).

Studies such as these form the basis for the recent reports of smoking bans slashing heart attacks by ‘up to a third’. The Circulation paper gathers them together and concludes that, on average, smoking bans cause rates of acute myocardial infarction to fall by 17 per cent. It includes the studies from Ohio and Italy, as well as three studies that have never been published and have only been ‘reported at meetings’.

The paper does not, however, include a mammoth (published) study of the entire United States, which concluded: ‘In contrast with smaller regional studies, we find that workplace bans are not associated with statistically significant short-term declines in mortality or hospital admissions for myocardial infarction or other diseases.’ (8)

Nor does it include an (unpublished) paper which found no statistically significant fall in heart attacks amongst the entire populations of California, Florida, New York and Oregon (9).

Perhaps the most remarkable aspect of the ongoing heart-miracle farrago is the eagerness to focus on small studies when complete hospital data is so freely available. It is extraordinary that no BBC journalist, for example, has thought of taking a few minutes to see how many people were rushed to hospital with acute myocardial infarction before and after the smoking bans of England, Scotland and Wales. If they did so, they would see that smokefree legislation has had no tangible influence on heart attack rates at all.

The graphs below show the number of emergency admissions for acute myocardial infarction, with the arrow indicating the start of the smoking ban. What is abundantly clear in each case is that the number of heart attack admissions has been falling for some time. Far from causing further dramatic cuts in heart attack rates, the bans had no discernible effect.

Scotland

The press said: ‘Heart attacks drop by 17 per cent after smoking ban’ ( Telegraph)

The data says:



Wales

The press said: ‘The number of patients suffering a heart attack in Wales has fallen dramatically following the ban on smoking. (Wales Online)

The data says:



England

The press said: ‘Heart attacks plummet after smoking ban’ (The Sunday Times)

The data says:



Publicly accessible hospital admissions data is like kryptonite to those who are so eager to believe in miracles. In most epidemiological studies pertaining to secondhand smoke, the raw data is not published. Here, it is open to all and shows quite clearly that the long-term downward trend in heart attacks has not been affected in any way by the implementation of smoking bans. It provides such a simple and straightforward rebuttal to the heart attack ‘slashing’ hypothesis that one wonders what level of hubris drives those who still espouse it.

The three graphs above cover a population larger than the sample groups in all the studies reviewed in Circulation combined, but no matter how much empirical evidence exposes the fantasy of the Helena miracle, it may be too late for the anti-smoking lobby to back down on this issue. Too many reputations are at stake.

After five years of covering these stories so uncritically, the same may be true of the media. One can scarcely blame newspapers for covering stories that offer such dramatic conclusions as the heart miracles. The irony is that if they dug just a little deeper, they might find a more interesting, and more believable, tale of human folly.



(1) Heart attacks plummet after smoking ban, The Sunday Times, 13 September 2009

(2) Smoking ban slashes heart attacks by up to a third across world, Scotsman, 22 September 2009

(3) ASH Daily News for 15 September 2009, Action on Smoking and Health, 15 September 2009

(4) Declines in Acute Myocardial Infarction After Smoke-Free Laws and Individual Risk Attributable to Secondhand Smoke, Circulation, 21 September 2009

(5) Reduced incidence of admissions for myocardial infarction associated with public smoking ban: before and after study, British Medical Journal, 2004;328:977-980

(6) The impact of a smoking ban on hospital admissions for coronary heart disease, Preventative Medicine, 2007 Jul;45(1):3-8. Epub 2007 Apr 4

(7) Short-term effects of Italian smoking regulation on rates of hospital admission for acute myocardial infarction, 29 August 2006

(8) Changes in U.S. Hospitalization and Mortality Rates Following Smoking Bans, National Bureau of Economic Research, March 2009

(9) Do Smoking Bans cause a 27 to 40% drop in admissions for myocardial infarction in hospitals?, The Smoker’s Club

(10) Coronary heart disease: hospital activity, ISD Scotland

(11) Hospital admissions date online, Health Solutions Wales

(12) Hospital Episode Statistics, HES Online

Originally published by Spiked (24/9/09)



Wednesday, 2 September 2009

1+1=11: The Helena Miracle (part 3)

The Helena Miracle is perhaps the archetypal junk science study. Now five years old, there is little more that can be said about its shocking methodology and ludicrous conclusion. This piece of nonsense has been thoroughly debunked by many writers, including myself and I would only offer one further observation.

For those unfamiliar with the story, the Helena Miracle is the name given to a study written by Stanton Glantz and two anti-smoking activists which purported to show that a short-lived smoking ban in the small town of Helena, Montana resulted in a 'nearly 60%' fall in heart attack admissions to local hospitals. The unavoidable conclusion, as publicised in a worldwide press release sent out by Americans for Nonsmokers' Rights (ANR), was that reducing exposure to secondhand smoke immediately saved lives.

The study was so flawed as to be comical. No questions had been asked of any of the patients regarding their exposure to secondhand smoke, their lifestyles, diet or age. Two-thirds of them turned out to be either current or former smokers. It transpired that the authors of the paper had merely counted heart attack cases and ascribed their own explanation to it. Furthermore, the numbers involved were ridiculously small; there had been an average of seven cases a month prior to the ban and four cases after it.

Nevertheless, it was immediately picked up by the international media and august news-gathering organisations such as the BBC ("Town slashes heart attacks") and The New York Times ("The Secondhand Smoking Gun") without asking even the most basic questions of the report. It was thoroughly reported in the UK, where the prospect of a national smoking ban was beginning to raise its head, and journalists were quick to extrapolate the findings from Helena onto the population of the UK ("Smoking ban could halve number of heart attacks" - The Independent). New Scientist, to its shame, covered it with the headline "Public smoking ban slashes heart attacks", a phrase so close to the title of the ANR press release that it is most charitable to assume the journal had not seen the (still unpublished) study and instead took the ANR's claim on trust.

But there was a problem with the study that went beyond its atrocious methodology and the obvious bias of its authors. If the smoking ban was responsible for reducing heart attack admissions by 60%, then secondhand smoke must have been responsible for 60% of the heart attacks in Helena before the ban. And since Helena was a typical American town - why else would they do an epidemiological study there? - the only conclusion could be that passive smoking was responsible for the majority of heart attacks in the US.

And, of course, the Helena smoking ban did not eliminate passive smoking. It merely reduced it in bars, restaurants and workplaces. More accurately, then, we should say that passive smoking in some places is responsible for 60% of heart attacks. Perhaps passive smoking in the home causes the other 40% and, therefore, secondhand smoke is the sole cause of heart attacks?

The glaring problem was that active smoking was not responsible for anything close to 60% of heart attacks. No health group has ever claimed that active and passive smoking combined is responsible for any more than 20% of heart disease cases and, of course, the vast majority of these are attributed to active smoking. It was therefore risible to suggest that "nearly 60%" of heart attacks could have been triggered by secondhand smoke exposure in so-called public places. The killer flaw with the Helena Miracle was not in the study itself - awful though it was - but with the conclusion. As with Repace's tornado claim, it is not necessary to question the validity of the passive smoking theory in order to debunk the Helena miracle. Even if we suspend disbelief and accept that passive smoking is lethal to nonsmokers, there is no way on earth that it can possibly be responsible for anything like 60% of all heart attacks.

The mainstream media did not pick up on this obvious point. However, it did not escape everyone's attention and Glantz was called to task on it. It is his response to the criticism that the Helena effect was far too large to be believable that is the focus of this article. His defence was:

"The individual risk of heart attack associated with passive smoking is about 30%, which is within the margin of error of the 60% drop we saw in Helena."(1)

If Glantz believed this then he is, quite simply, mathematically illiterate. He makes the elementary error of confusing relative risk (to the individual) with absolute risk (to the population).

To give an example, driving while drunk might increase the risk of crashing your car by 90% but that does not mean that the number of car crashes in a country will fall by 90% if no one drives while drunk. The reason is simple: not all car crashes are caused by drunks. Let's say - for the sake of argument - that 5% of all car crashes are caused by drunk driving. Eliminating drunk driving entirely will therefore reduce car crashes by 5% but not by 90%. The 90% figure for individual risk has no bearing on the overall incidence of car crashes.

This really is basic stuff. Let us, for a moment, take Glantz seriously when he says that passive smoking increases an individual's risk of a heart attack by 30%. Let us also assume that obesity, diabetes, physical inactivity, stress, excessive alcohol, too little alcohol, high cholesterol, high blood pressure and a family history of heart disease also increase risk by the same amount (2). Add in passive smoking and we have ten factors which increase heart attack risk by 30%. Now let us say that each of these factors is responsible for 100 heart attacks a year in a community = 1,000 heart attacks in total. If we eliminate all secondhand smoke exposure from that community then the most we can possibly hope for is a fall in the heart attack rate from 1,000 to 900 ie. 10%. Therefore, even if a smoking ban eliminates secondhand smoke exposure entirely - which it won't - it cannot possibly bring about more than a 10% fall.

And that is just when we take 10 risk factors into account. In fact - according to the World Health Organisation (3) - there are over 300 risk factors for heart disease. So let us go back to our theoretical community and say that there are 300 factors that cause 100 deaths each. This equals 30,000 deaths and one factor - passive smoking - causes 100 of them. Passive smoking is therefore responsible for 0.3% of all the heart attacks in the community. It cannot be responsible for any more. If secondhand smoke is removed completely, the heart attack rate cannot fall by more than 0.3%.

Lest I be accused of peddling junk science myself, I should quickly add that I am in no way conjuring up estimates of how many people are killed by passive smoking, active smoking, obesity, stress or anything else. This is nothing more than an illustration of the difference between relative and absolute risk but I hope it suffices. I am not claiming that each of the WHO's 300 risk factors raise individual risk by exactly 30% or are responsible for exactly 0.3% of all heart attacks. The major risk factors - genetics, stress, smoking and so on - have far more effect than others, including passive smoking. But this only underlines how insignificant secondhand smoke is in the overall picture.

Even if you believe that secondhand smoke exposure does raise individual risk by 30% you must accept that its contribution to total heart attack incidence cannot possibly be anything close to 30%, let alone the 60% initially claimed by Glantz (when the study was eventually published in the British Medical Journal (4), the percentage had fallen to 40%, a discrepancy that was never explained*.) And once you accept that, you must accept that the conclusion of the Helena study is not just flawed but mathematically impossible.

At this point you might say: "Well, smoking bans may not save as many lives as some of the more fanatical anti-smoking types claim, but they must still save some lives". And, in a way, this is the message that all the studies covered in this series of articles want you to be left with. Any intelligent person can see that "tornado-level ventilation" is not required to disperse secondhand smoke. Anyone with any common sense can see that secondhand smoke cannot be "more dangerous" than firsthand smoke. And it doesn't take much to work out that passive smoking cannot be responsible for 70%, 60%, 40%, 27%, 17% or 11% of all heart attacks. Even if everything the anti-smoking groups say about passive smoking is true, it would be extraordinary if a smoking ban could result in even a 1% drop in heart attacks.

No one wants to see themselves as gullible by believing big lies but, equally, no one wants to be seen as a crank by dismissing the whole thing. Big lies are useful to the anti-smoking movement because they give intelligent people the scope to be sceptical about what they see as 'exaggerations' while inviting them to conclude that there must be some truth at the heart of the exaggeration. The big lie does not have to be swallowed whole. It only has to spark the thought that there is no (secondhand) smoke without fire.

The anti-smoking movement's descent into hyperbole almost invites us to be cynical about the big lies while insisting that we believe the little lies. But why should we believe either? After all, the same people are responsible for both. Stanton Glantz's botched defence of his Helena study rested on his claim that passive smoking increases heart disease risk by 30% but he does not mention that this figure comes from a paper written by himself in 1991; a report that was rejected by the Environmental Protection Agency when he tried to have it tied to their notorious 1992 report. James Repace gave us the tornado-level winds but he was also an early proponent of the passive smoking theory in the late 1970s and today makes a living as a professional 'secondhand smoke consultant'.

We should be able to expect reliable and rational information from the world's foremost medical journals and, frankly, shame on the British Medical Journal for publishing the Helena study. And shame on Stanton Glantz - a man who has written a textbook on biostatistics - for submitting such nonsense for publication.
* All mention of the 60% figure has been removed from the Americans for Nonsmokers' Rights website. However the original press release can still be viewed here.

(1) http://listsrv.ucsf.edu/OldArchives/hypermail_archives/stanglantz-l/0070.html

(2) For a list of the major causes of heart disease see: http://www.americanheart.org/presenter.jhtml%3Fidentifier%3D4726+risk+factors+heart+disease&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=1&gl=uk

(3) http://www.who.int/cardiovascular_diseases/en/cvd_atlas_03_risk_factors.pdf (pdf) To name just a few other risk factors: depression, excess homocysteine, blood coagulation, inflammation, lipoprotein, hypertrophy

(4) http://bmj.bmjjournals.com/cgi/content/full/328/7446/977

Wednesday, 31 October 2012

Is that a fact?

The big lie has returned. From NPR:

When smoking is banned in bars and workplaces, the number of people who suffer heart attacks and die drops within months, according to two new studies.

They found benefits not only in saving lives, but in lowering the cost of medical care for heart attacks, stroke and other smoking-related illnesses. It's the best evidence yet demonstrating big, swift health improvements when secondhand smoke is banished.

"We should now accept this as fact," says Richard Hurt, a professor of medicine at the Mayo Clinic who led one of the studies. Tobacco industry arguments that secondhand smoke isn't a major risk factor for heart disease, he says, are "just nonsense," because the only risk factor that changed in those 18 months was secondhand smoke. People's cholesterol and blood pressure stayed the same, and obesity rates increased.

And the man who invented this fraudulent field of pseudoscience is on hand for a comment of his own:

"It's just a gigantic effect," says Stanton Glantz, director of the Center for Tobacco Control Research and Education at UCSF, and a leader on the study. "There's nothing else you can do that's going to have that big an effect that fast."

Forgive my scepticism, Stanton, it's just that every time hospital admissions data are publicly available, they show these 'heart miracle' studies to be castles made of sand.

The latest effort focuses on Olmstead County, Minnesota, where the heart attack rate fell by 33 per cent between 2001 and 2009. All the ingredients of a heart miracle scam are in place.

Yes, these—ahem—'findings' were published by press release a year ago.

Yes, it's another small locality.

Yes, there's no control group to compare it to.

Yes, the timeframe studied is peculiar (the smoking ban was enacted in 2007).

Yes, heart attack rates have been falling all around the world with or without smoking bans (in the UK, for example, the heart attack rate fell by 50 per cent between 2002 and 2010.)

And yes, once again, the hospital admissions data make a mockery of the claim that the smoking ban 'caused' the fall in heart attacks. As Michael Siegel showed yesterday, the heart attack 'plunged' by a similar rate in the rest of Minnesota. And today, he has found data which show that the heart attack mortality rate which was falling steeply before the ban and then rose after it. Oh dear.

Thus, it is clear that the observed 33% reduction in heart attacks in Olmsted County during the study period is not attributable to the smoking ban.

Note that even if one looks only at hospital admissions for heart attacks in Minnesota, there was a 23% decline in these admissions between 2001 and 2006 alone (the data is not provided by HCUP past 2006). However, if one extrapolates to the year 2009 based on the secular rate of decline in the 2001-2006 period, the estimated number of hospital admissions for heart attacks in 2009 represents a drop of 34% from 2001.

In other words, in the absence of a smoking ban, heart attack admissions in Olmsted County would have been expected to drop by 34%. In the presence of the smoking ban, heart attack rates dropped by 33%.

Thus, it appears that the observed decline in heart attacks in Olmsted County is roughly representative of the overall trend in heart attacks in the state as a whole. In this light, the present study hardly supports a conclusion that the Olmsted County smoking bans produced a 33% decline in heart attacks.

If these are "definitive" results, I'd hate to see what "tentative" results look like.

Quite. Frankly, this is getting boring. It's the same crude trick again and again. Stop it.



Tuesday, 14 February 2017

The smoking ban miracle hoax

Jacob Grier has written an excellent article for Slate about the junk science used to justify smoking bans. In particular, he looks at the ludicrous heart attack miracles than supposedly take place whenever people are prevented from smoking in pubs.

When studies sampling larger populations finally appeared, the reported declines in heart attacks began to shrink. A study of the Piedmont region of Italy found a much lower decline of 11 percent, though curiously only for residents under 60 years of age. England, which implemented a smoking ban nationwide, presented the first opportunity to study the matter on a national scale. Researchers there credited the ban with a heart attack reduction of just over 2 percent nationwide.

Critics noted that the rate of heart attacks in England had also been falling in the years prior to the ban and that the reason for the decline was still not clear. Regardless, the data there made it obvious that the miraculous reductions claimed in smaller studies were unrealistically high. Even so, despite acknowledging the wide variation in findings and the admitted methodological limitations of the studies, a 2009 meta-analysis conducted by the Institute of Medicine concluded that the impact of smoking bans on short-term heart attack rates was real and substantial: “Even a small amount of exposure to secondhand smoke… can cause a heart attack,” one member of the IOM panel informed the New York Times, urging that “smoking bans need to be put in place as quickly as possible.”
This report had, however, omitted one of the largest studies of secondhand smoke and heart attacks conducted to date. A 2008 study covering the entire country of New Zealand—a population smaller than England’s, but bigger than the American towns previously studied—found no significant effects on heart attacks or unstable angina in the year following implementation of a smoking ban; hospitalizations for the former had actually increased.

Contradictory research continued to come in. A clever study led by researchers at RAND Corp. in 2010 tested the possibility that the large reductions identified in small communities were due to chance. They assembled a massive data set that allowed them to essentially replicate studies like those in Helena, Pueblo, and Bowling Green, but on an unprecedented scale. Whereas those studies had compared just one small community to another, the RAND paper compared all possible pairings of communities affected by smoking bans to all possible controls, for a total of more than 15,000 pairings. They stratified results by age in case there were differential effects on the young, working age adults, or the elderly. And in an improvement on most other studies, they also controlled for existing trends in the rate of heart attacks.

The study found no statistically significant decrease in heart attacks among any age group. The data also suggested that fluctuations in heart attack rates were common, indicating that comparisons of small communities would frequently turn up dramatic reductions due purely to chance; large increases in heart attacks happened about as often. This explained the headline-grabbing dramatic results in places like Helena or Monroe County that eluded replication in larger jurisdictions. The conclusion of the study was blunt: “We find no evidence that legislated U.S. smoking bans were associated with short-term reductions in hospital admissions for acute myocardial infarction or other diseases in the elderly, children or working age adults.”

A 2012 study of six American states that had instituted smoking bans came to a similar conclusion. So did a 2014 study, which is notable for being co-authored by some of the same researchers who had previously published papers suggesting that the Colorado towns of Pueblo and Greeley had experienced reduced rates of heart attacks after implementing smoking bans. When Colorado enacted a statewide ban, the authors had an opportunity to see if their earlier results could be duplicated across the larger population of nearly 5 million people. No effect appeared. As an additional test, they re-examined the data excluding 11 jurisdictions that had already implemented comprehensive smoking bans: The statewide ban still showed no effect.

In the paper’s admirably honest commentary, the authors reflected on the reasons that earlier studies, including their own, had overstated the impact of smoking bans. The first is that small sample sizes allowed random variances in data to be mistaken for real effects. The second is that most previous studies failed to account for existing downward trends in the rate of heart attacks. And the third is publication bias: Since no one believes that smoking bans increase heart attacks, few would bother submitting or publishing studies that show a positive correlation or null effect. Thus the published record is likely unintentionally biased toward showing a larger effect than truly exists.


Do read it all.

Tuesday, 8 December 2009

The Welsh miracle is not dead. It just smells bad.


When it comes to heart attack miracles, it's difficult to pick the most preposterous. Heart miracles constitute a sub-genre of pseudo-science which is so comically ill-considered it almost makes other quackery seem reasonable. 

At the moment, only a relatively small number of people are in on the joke (including Dr Siegel, who has just exposed yet another), but we can console ourselves that many of these studies have appeared in print, thereby leaving a paper trail for future historians to follow when they rake over the coals of this decade's exodus from rational thought.

One of the silliest heart miracles was reported last year. It concerned the case of Wales, which saw a rise in heart attacks in the five months following the Welsh smoking ban and no significant fall in the post-ban year overall. This - you might think - would be enough for tobacco controllers to turn a blind eye to the green, green hills of Wales, but no. 

With a sneakiness that bordered on the heroic, a Welsh politician named Chris Franks spotted that the 4th quarter of the post-ban year saw fewer heart attacks than the same period of 2006. He used his influence to get the "story" into Wales' Daily Post, where he found a willing accomplice in the form of journalist Tom Bodden who wrote an article headlined: 'Fewer Heart Attacks in Wake Of Smoking Ban'.

This was all back in June 2008. It got a little coverage elsewhere but not very much. ASH and the Department of Health didn't want to touch it because they knew that it was all a scam. I explained why it was a scam on my website and at Spiked. Dr Siegel did likewise. So did Reason.

Now, via Jacob Grier, I see that this ancient corpse has been exhumed and Tom Bodden (for it is he again) is trying to breathe new life into it:

Smoking ban ‘sees fall in heart attacks’ in Wales

NEW figures this week are expected to reveal how the first full year of the public smoking ban in Wales heralded a steep decline in heart attacks.

The findings will be contained in the Chief Medical Officer for Wales’ annual report showing hospital admissions have fallen since the ban came into force.

I will be intrigued if the Chief Medical Officer does make such a claim, because it is completely untrue. Not only is it untrue, it has become even less true - if such a thing is possible - since I last wrote about it.

You see, reading all again this inspired me to return to the NHS Wales hospital admissions data (available at Health Solutions Wales). Since I last discussed the Welsh miracle, another year's data have become available. And - wouldn't you know it? - heart attacks increased last year. (Some readers may recall a similar phenomenon in Scotland).

As you can see from the graph below, there was no "steep decline" in the heart attack rate in Wales after the smoking ban. The rate of decline followed the exact same trend of the previous two years. But you will also notice a rise in heart attacks in the second year of the ban - the first rise for seven years. 



To put it in precise terms, the number of Welsh residents rushed to hospital with acute myocardial infarction rose from 3,999 (2007/08) to 4,126 (2008/09)*. Even if you add in emergency admissions for angina and subsequent acute myocardial infarction, there is a rise from 9,783 to 9,851. It doesn't matter whether you look at Welsh residents or Welsh hospitals (there are different statistics for both), the story is always the same. 

So what does Welsh Health Minister Edwina Hart have to say in the face of this unequivocal evidence that hospital admissions for heart attacks went up last year?

"The Chief Medical Officer’s annual report to be published later this week will show that hospital admissions for heart attacks were reduced last year."

This would appear to be from the horse's mouth, which is worrying. If the Health Minister is correct and the Chief Medical Officer does indeed announce that "hospital admissions for heart attacks were reduced last year" there will only be one explanation. 

The Chief Medical Officer must be a liar.


*Emergency admissions for acute myocardial infarction (Welsh residents):

2000/01: 4891
2001/02: 5398
2002/03: 5374
2003/04: 5263
2004/05: 4719
2005/06: 4425
2006/07: 4180
2007/08: 3999
2008/09: 4126

The Welsh smoking ban was enacted on April 2 2007. There were no exemptions.




Wednesday, 9 November 2011

The North Carolina smoking ban/heart attack hoax

Stop me if you think you've heard this one before.

From the University of San Francisco (note the byline)...

Heart attacks down 21 percent in the first year after the North Carolina smokefree restuarant and bar law took effect

Submitted by sglantz on Wed, 2011-11-09 11:54

The evidence that strong smokefree laws provide large and immediate health benefits just keeps piling up.

The latest study, released today, found a 21 percent drop in emergency room admission for heart attacks during the first year of the law, saving an estimated $3.4 to $4.3 million in heath care costs. This is serious money, particularly as both government and the private sector struggle to keep health costs down.

These real documented and rapid benefits not just in terms of health, but the economy, show that the economic argument on smokefree policies has clearly shifted away from the tobacco industry and its allies to the health side.

Real and documented, you say? So we can assume, at the very least, that there were 21% fewer heart attacks after the smoking ban?

Not even that, I'm afraid. Not even close. As the study shows, there were 9,066 heart attacks in 2008. This fell by 10.5% to 8,113 in 2009. The smoking ban came in at the start of 2010. In that year, there were 7,669 heart attacks—a decline of 5.5%.

The researchers have even helpfully included a graph in which you can clearly see the heart attack rate falling before the ban and then leveling off somewhat after the ban.




As if to rub our noses in it, the researchers spell out exactly what the trend was.

Interestingly, the rates appear to have consistently declined between the year 2008 and 2009; after that period the rates leveled off at a consistently lower level in the year 2010.

Er, yeah. So where on earth does this claim that there was "a 21 percent drop in emergency room admission for heart attacks during the first year of the law" come from?

The answer is that they did a Gilmore. They made a computer model. You may recall Anna Gilmore and her band of merry women reinterpreting the no-change-there-then English heart attack data and declaring that 2.4% of the 4.2% drop was attributable to the smoking ban. Unprovable (she made no attempt to prove it) but also unfalsifiable.

This new study takes that approach to absurd new depths. Whereas Gilmore claimed that a portion of the drop in heart attacks was due to the smoking ban, this model says that the smoking ban reduced the heart attack rate by 21%, despite the actual heart attack rate only falling by 5.5%.

You almost have to admire the sheer audacity of these people. Every time I think there is no way they can keep flogging this dead horse, they come up with another ruse.

Here is a study which unequivocally shows that the smoking ban had absolutely no effect on the heart attack rate. If anything, the year after the smoking ban saw rather more heart attacks that would be predicted based on the preceding years. The study provides all the data you need to see that the heart attack rate fell by 5.5% after the smoking ban and yet it concludes—based on a demonstrably ludicrous computer model—that the smoking ban reduced the heart attack rate by 21%. When your computer gives you information like that it's time to turn it off and turn it on again.

And yet you can be sure that when this study is inevitably reported, the facts will not be allowed to stand in the way. The number of people who actually went to hospital with a heart attack will become irrelevant (although it's fitting that bans based on imaginary deaths are saving imaginary lives). The fiction has become the reality. The model has spoken. "There were 21% fewer heart attacks after the smoking ban. Here's Tom with the weather..."

Sunday, 7 August 2011

The heart miracle scam revisited

One of the more blatant scientific scams of recent years has been the heart miracle phenomenon, in which tobacco control campaigners create studies showing a dramatic fall in heart attacks after smoking bans. It began when Stanton Glantz of Americans for Nonsmokers' Right announced the 'Helena miracle' in 2003, claiming a 60% drop in heart attacks after the smoking ban in this small town in Montana (later revised to 40%). It continued through places like Bowling Green, Ohio (47%) and Pueblo, Colorado (41%).

These places are not exactly major conurbations, you may have noticed, and the numbers of heart attacks are so low—often single or double figures—that large fluctuations are common. When whole countries have been studied, advocates have been forced to resort to methodological jiggery-pokery (Scotland, 17%) and bald, unverifiable assertions (England, 2.4%).

Stanton Glantz has produced two meta-analyses in an attempt to shore up his hypothesis, claiming that heart attacks fall by 27%, and then 17%, after smoking bans are enacted.

But when the actual hospital admissions data are made available, they invariably fail to provide any evidence of an effect of smoking bans on the heart attack rate. The statistics from Denmark, Wales, Australia, England, Scotland, New Zealand and the United States have all failed to support the smoking ban/heart miracle hypothesis.

What should we trust? The evidence from places like Bowling Green, Ohio or the evidence from the entire USA? It has been obvious from the very beginning that anti-smoking campaigners have been mining the data to find big drops in heart attacks that roughly coincide with smoking bans. A study recently presented to an American Heart Association conference illustrates how easy this cherry-picking can be.

The study's finding are very interesting. The researchers looked at 74 US cities and found that the heart miracle effect has now fallen to just 3% (0.97 (0.95-99)). When the sample was limited to cities where the smokefree law was "meaningful"—ie. where there was a full smoking ban, rather than just restrictions—the effect disappeared entirely (0.99 (0.96-1.02). (Meaning that cities with lax smoking bans saw a bigger fall in heart attacks than those with "meaningful" smoking bans. Once again, the evidence fails to fit the theory.)

A drawback of the study is that there is no indication of how much the heart attack rate was falling before the ban, nor do the researchers compare rates to those in the cities which didn't have a smoking ban. When the study is published—if it is—hopefully the researchers will use a control group and look at the long-term trend.

What we do know is that rates of heart disease are falling in the USA, as they are in the UK and Europe. Even if one picks the more generous 3% figure, a modest decline of this order is likely to be in line with the secular trend. In other words: the smoking bans didn't make any difference.

If you look at the cities which brought in full smoking bans, you can see there is a great deal of variation in the heart attack rate with some going up, some going down and some going nowhere.



The variation is so great that no honest statistician would claim that there is any trend to be found amongst the data. But notice that four of the cities showed a statistically significant reduction in heart attacks and that the reduction was quite strong (at around 25%-30%). Now put yourself in the shoes of the tobacco control advocate who wants to show that smoking bans have a major effect on the heart attack rate. Which city would you choose to write your paper about? Evanston or Flagstaff?

The question, I think, answers itself. This is how they have been doing it. This is how we end up with 'news stories' like this from the BBC in 2003:

Town slashes heart attacks

Banning smoking in public places could prevent hundreds of deaths from heart disease, according to a study in a small US town.

Heart attacks in Helena, Montana, fell dramatically when smoking in public places was banned for six months last year.

The number of admissions dropped to fewer than four a month - a fall of nearly 60%.

From "nearly 60%" to nearly zero in just 8 years. What a ridiculous fraud this whole thing has been and how pathetic that so many have fallen for it.

Thanks to Michael J. McFadden for the tip.

Thursday, 16 December 2010

Is this the love child of Glantz and Gilmore?

The other day I was thinking of running a worst-junk-science-of-the-year poll. Thank God I bided my time otherwise I would have missed the chance to nominate this beauty.

Isle of Man smoking ban 'cuts heart attacks'

A ban on smoking in public places has reduced heart attack admissions, according to research commissioned by the Isle of Man's Department of Health.

The department has compared admissions in the two years prior to introduction of the ban on 30 March 2008 and the two years since.

It discovered that the number of men over 55 admitted for heart attacks had dropped since the ban.

But if we take a look at the 'study' (unpublished and not peer-reviewed, not that that makes a lot of difference these days), a very different picture emerges:




Do my eyes deceive me or does this graph show that there significantly more heart attacks after the smoking ban?

They don't and there were. In the 23 months before the smoking ban, there were 109 heart attack admissions, or 4.7 per month. In the 23 months after the smoking ban, there were 153 heart attacks, or 6.65 per month.In what universe does this count as a drop in heart attacks?

In the crazy world of tobacco control, that's where. Note the regression lines, designed to take your eye off what is actually happening. Note how the second half of the graph has a line that is driven down by the lowish figure for the last month shown (since the next month needed to make it a full two years has mysteriously gone missing).

This is a method taken straight out of the Anna Gilmore's box of tricks, with a dash of Glantz's Helena magic thrown in for good measure (small community, inaccessible hospital records, data mining etc.). If there isn't a drop in heart attacks, you simply 'predict' how many would have occurred if the smoking ban hadn't come in and make sure your prediction is higher than the real number. And before you know it the BBC will be falling over itself to report that "a ban on smoking in public places has reduced heart attack admissions" and the New England Journal of Medicine will be beating a path to your door.

And the feeble effort shown above is the best this researcher—a maths student at Rutherford Polytechnic the University of Northumbria—could conjure up. The graph that shows all heart attack admissions, (ie. the relevant, non-cherry-picked data set) is even less compelling.





Notice that before the ban, there were usually fewer than ten heart attack admissions. Notice, too, that after the ban the rate was usually well above ten. And, of course, there were more heart attacks in total after the ban than before it. And, as the flat black line shows, the monthly rate of admissions did not go down one bit in the nigh-on two years after the ban.

But you're not supposed to look at any of that. Instead, you are invited to look at the upwards line in the pre-ban period and assume that the rate would have continued rising, even though that line only goes up because of a big jump (by Isle of Man standards) to 14 cases shortly before the ban. Nor are you supposed to notice that any responsible statistician would identify that unusual leap as a statistical artifact. The fact that more than two-thirds of the data points are below the regression shows that it's being contorted by an outlier.

It's truly unbelievable that this sort of stuff gets taken seriously. Or it would be if it didn't happen every few months. This is a world where a flat line equals a decline, and a 50% increase in heart attacks equals a reduction in heart attacks.

In a year that has seen fierce competition for the title, Ms Howda Jwad of Northumbria University—for it is she—may just have clinched the inaugural World's Worst Junk Science Award in the dying days of the year. Glantz, Pell, Gilmore, Winickoff—it's time to up your game.


Thanks to Brian Bond for the tip

Friday, 12 January 2024

Vaping and heart attacks

Junk science veteran Stanton Glantz is excited about a study that purports to show that vaping causes heart attacks (myocardial infarction). The study was published in November last year but appeared in the obscure, low status (and possibly predatory) journal Cureus and, thankfully, the media never picked it up.

The author, Talal Alzahrani, had previously produced a widely criticised study claiming that e-cigarette use is associated with heart attacks which included dual users of vapes and cigarettes and therefore could not isolate the effect of smoking from the putative effect of vaping. Glantz was a co-author. Glantz himself has had a study claiming that vaping causes heart attacks retracted. The new study, written by Alzahrani alone, seeks to avoid the earlier problem by looking only at vapers who say that they have never smoked. 

As Glantz says on his blog:
 

To get enough adult e-cigarette users who never smoked, Alzahrani combined data from the US National Health Interview Surveys from 2014 through 2021, which yielded 1237 never smoking e-cigarette users.  After controlling for other risk factors for heart attack, he found that current e-cigarette users had 2.6 times the odds of having had a heart attack as non-e-cigarette users (95% CI 1.44-4.77) compared with never smokers who did not use e-cigarettes.

 
This is not far off the risk associated with smoking and is highly implausible from the outset since vapes do not contain many of the substances in cigarettes that are known to cause heart disease. The most suspicious thing about the study is that it does not show how many heart attacks occurred among the vaping and non-vaping groups. All we are given are the adjusted relative risks.

And there must have been some huge adjustments because everything about the vaping group implies that they would suffer fewer heart attacks.
 
A total of 139,697 subjects were never users, and 1,237 subjects were current e-cigarette users. The data analysis showed that current e-cigarette users were significantly younger than never users. E-cigarette users were less likely to be female (40% vs. 60%, p <0.01), or have diabetes (3% vs. 10%, p <0.01), have hypertension (11% vs. 32%, p <0.01), hypercholesterolemia (8% vs. 27%, p <0.01), have or be overweight or obese (56% vs. 65%, p <0.01) compared to never users.
 
The average age of the vapers was 28 whereas the average age of the control group was 50. Heart attacks are very rare among young people and there were only 1,237 never-smoking vapers to study. If you can find the data from the US National Health Interview Surveys, you may be able to confirm or deny, but I would bet the following:

Firstly, that there were a tiny number of heart attacks among the never-smoking vapers. I would be very surprised if there were more than ten.

Secondly, that a larger proportion of the controls had a heart attack than the never-smoking vapers.

Thirdly, that the claimed association between vaping and heart attacks is purely the result of adjustments made to the data that defy logic.

Why else would he not show the unadjusted figures? Why else would he not submit his study - which, if its findings were true, is incredibly important - to a decent journal?  

Nullius in verba.



Monday, 8 December 2014

The heart attack hoax

A study published in the British Medical Journal earlier this year looked at the causes of the 43 per cent decline in heart disease mortality that took place in Scotland between 2000 and 2010. By far the biggest reasons given were medical treatment (of which the largest contribution came from the use of statins) and improvements in risk factors (mostly coming from reductions in blood pressure).

Results
5770 fewer deaths from coronary heart disease occurred in 2010 than would be expected if the 2000 mortality rates had persisted (8042 rather than 13 813). This reflected a 43% fall in coronary heart disease mortality rates (from 262 to 148 deaths per 100 000). Improved treatments accounted for approximately 43% (95% confidence interval 33% to 61%) of the fall in mortality, and this benefit was evenly distributed across deprivation fifths. Notable treatment contributions came from primary prevention for hypercholesterolaemia (13%), secondary prevention drugs (11%), and chronic angina treatments (7%).

Risk factor improvements accounted for approximately 39% (28% to 49%) of the fall in mortality (44% in the most deprived fifth compared with only 36% in the most affluent fifth). Reductions in systolic blood pressure contributed more than one third (37%) of the decline in mortality, with no socioeconomic patterning.

Smaller contributions came from falls in total cholesterol (9%), smoking (4%), and inactivity (2%).

One contribution is conspicuous by its absence. You may recall the widely circulated claim that was made 2007:

Smoking ban brings big cut in heart attacks in Scotland, study finds

The number of people being taken to hospital with heart attacks in Scotland has fallen significantly since the smoking ban was introduced, the most detailed study into the impact of the measure has revealed.

Researchers found a 17% drop in the number of people admitted for heart attacks in the year since the ban came into force, compared with an average 3% reduction a year over the previous decade.

So where does the smoking ban rank in the list of factors that led to the millennial drop in heart disease mortality?

Nowhere. It doesn't get a mention. Smoking is listed as one of the "behavioural risk factors [that] made a modest contribution to deaths prevented or postponed" and the authors estimate that the four percentage point decline in smoking rates "contributed approximately 210 fewer deaths or 4% [of the overall decline]". But despite considering "a comprehensive range of risk factors", the smoking ban doesn't feature at all.

It's not difficult to see why. As I have pointed out ad nauseum, all the official data from ISD Scotland shows that rates of heart attack, angina and heart disease were completely unaffected by smoking ban (which came into force in March 2006). The graphs below show deaths from heart attacks (acute myocardial infarction) and total mortality from heart disease. (See here for the data. Note that ISD Scotland says that the increase in heart attacks from 2008/09 is "likely to be due to the introduction of more sensitive tests for diagnosis, meaning that more cases were now correctly diagnosed as heart attacks". Fortunately, we do not need these later figures to see what effect the March 2006 smoking ban had on heart attacks, ie. none.)





The claim that there was a steep and immediate decline in heart attack incidence after the ban is - and always has been - a lie. It now seems clear that the whole 'heart miracle' hypothesis came about as a result of publication bias. Hence, it merits no discussion by anyone wants to understand the reasons why heart disease mortality has been steadily declining over a decade or more.

Similarly, when a 2012 BMJ study looked at the reasons why heart attack mortality fell by half in England between 2002 and 2010, it made no mention of the 2007 smoking ban despite the earlier claim that "the ban on smoking in public has led to a dramatic fall in heart attack rates". That's because there never was a "dramatic fall in heart attack results".

Graph from the BBC


This illustrates the difference between health research and 'public health' research. 'Public health' research is generally policy-oriented junk science created for maximum media coverage whereas health research is designed to help clinicians understand what works and what doesn't. Health researchers tolerate the publication of 'public health' quackery because it is, they believe, all for a good cause, but incorporating it into their own work would invite mockery from colleagues and would amount to borderline medical negligence.

For their part, the 'public health' researchers have usually achieved their political goals by the time real evidence is published and so they cross their fingers and hope that nobody notices. They are rarely disappointed.



Tuesday, 15 September 2009

Why I don't believe in miracles


I mentioned yesterday that 'heart miracles' (studies that show the heart attack rate plunging by 10-40% after a smoking ban) are mathematically impossible. I would like to explain why.

The whole premise relies on a basic confusion between relative risk and absolute risk. Here is an example of a relative risk:

Drinking coffee whilst driving increases the risk of a fatal car crash by 80%

And here is an absolute risk:

U-boat crew in the Second World War had an 80% chance of dying at sea

The second example could also be phrased as '80% of U-boat crew died at sea during the Second World War'. It is the total risk for the individual, but it also tells us about the death rate amongst the whole group.

The first example is very different. It merely gives us the increased risk to the individual compared to that of the person who never drinks coffee whilst driving. 

A fallacious use of that first statistic would be to say that if motorists were banned from drinking coffee, the number of fatal car crashes would fall by 80%. A second's thought will tell you that that is obvious nonsense, because drinking coffee whilst driving is only one of many factors that increase risk whilst driving (and a fairly minor one, at that).

But it is precisely this fallacious reasoning that is used to justify the implausibly large drops in heart attacks reported in these smoking ban studies. The reasoning is:

Secondhand smoke exposure increases the risk of heart attack by 30%, therefore a smoking ban will reduce the number of heart attacks by 30%.

This could only be true if secondhand smoke was the only risk factor for heart disease and, of course, it isn't. According to the World Health Organisation there are 300 risk factors, including obesity, diabetes, physical inactivity, stress, high cholesterol, high blood pressure and a family history of heart disease - all of which increase risk more than passive smoking is said to.

It is a quite simple logical fallacy and yet it has been used from the very beginning with these heart miracle studies. Lest it be thought that I am putting words into anyone's mouth, here is how the authors of the Helena study (the first heart miracle study) explained a 40% drop in their 2004 paper (British Medical Journal).

[The study reported 40 heart attacks in the 6 months before the smoking ban and 24 after it]

The effect associated with the smoke-free law may seem large but is consistent with the observed effects of secondhand smoke on cardiac disease. 

Secondhand smoke increases the risk of a myocardial infarction by about 30%; if all this effect were to occur immediately, we would expect a fall of - 0.30 x 40.5 = - 12.2 in admissions during the six months the law was in effect, which is within the 95% confidence interval for the estimate of the effect (a drop of - 32.2 to - 0.8 admissions).

I have highlighted the key calculation. They are saying that 30% of heart attacks before the smoking ban were caused by secondhand smoke (12 of the 40 cases). Therefore, the smoking ban would be expected to save 12 lives. Their study actually found 16 fewer cases but, as they say, that is within the margin of error.

This is a fundamental error of logic. The 30% is the relative risk. It tells you nothing about the absolute risk to the population. 

So what is the absolute risk? I am not going to argue about the true effects of secondhand smoke here. For the purposes of this argument, let us go along with the Helena study authors and say that it increases risk by 30%. One of those authors was Stanton Glantz, a prominent and somewhat fanatical anti-smoking activist who has never been accused of underestimating the risks from secondhand smoke. I will use his figures so that I am not accused of cherry-picking. 

The US has around 630,000 deaths from heart disease each year. According to Stanton Glantz, 37,000 of these - or 5.9% - are caused by secondhand smoke. Even taking these figures, then, it should be self-evident that eliminating secondhand smoke could not possibly reduce heart attacks by more than 5.9%.

But smoking bans don't eliminate secondhand smoke. They eliminate it in bars, restaurants and other "public" places, but people continue to smoke in their homes and elsewhere. A smoking ban might perhaps halve secondhand smoke exposure, in which case it might - at the uppermost limit - reduce heart attacks by 3%.

I stress that I am not attempting to come up with my own estimate of how many lives are "saved" by smoking bans. Apply your own figures, by all means. The end result will be the same. It is mathematically impossible for a smoking ban to reduce the heart attack rate by 10-40% because even the most hyperbolic estimates indicate that secondhand smoke causes far fewer than 10% of heart attacks.


There is one other possibility - that smoking bans result in people giving up smoking and therefore suffer fewer heart attacks. On the face of it, this is a more plausible option. However, there is scant evidence that smoking bans actually do increase the quit rate, as Mark Wadsworth has been pointing out. 

It has been estimated that smoking is responsible for 11% of total cardiovascular deaths (PDF). Therefore, even if tobacco was banned and everybody stopped smoking, deaths from heart disease would not - could not - fall by more than 11%. The idea that banning smoking in bars and restaurants can reduce the heart attack rate more effectively than the total abolition of tobacco is plainly ludicrous.




Friday, 3 February 2012

Goodbye, you lizard scum

I have a post about the 'toxic sugar' canard over at the Adam Smith Institute. Before you go any further, please click over there and have a read.

I would like to leave it there, but there really is so much more to say. Seriously, has the whole world gone insane? I can understand why the media would pick up on a story like this and I can almost understand why a popular science magazine like Nature would publish the wacky article in the first place. It sells. What I don't get is why a bunch of nodding-dog journalists would respond with half-witted opinion pieces such as 'Evil is among us. And it’s called sugar'.

It's not that I didn't see it coming. I've been saying for years that the anti-tobacco blueprint would be rolled out to alcohol, food and fizzy drinks. It's just that I didn't think it would happen this quickly and when it did happen, I expected gales of laughter and an anti-nanny state backlash. This is manifestly not happening. That is a problem, but it isn't the biggest problem. The truly terrifying thing is that the intellectual climate is so retarded that Nature can publish such an article without feeling any shame.

Look at the people in the video below. Look at their self-satisfied little faces. These are the authors of the toxic sugar article. They are idiots. I do not say that to be insulting, but as a statement of fact. The woman on the right, in particular, should not be trusted with a pair of scissors. She calls herself a "medical sociologist" and works at UCSF. This should disqualify her from going anywhere near a scientific journal. She thinks that sugar is a poison because it is fermented to make alcohol. If you read the Daily Mail, alcohol is made by "distilling sugar". This is what we're up against: cretinous arguments made still more ludicrous by a woefully uneducated media.







The asshole on the left begins by saying "We are in the midst of the biggest public health crisis in the history of the world." He's not talking about the Black Death, cholera, influenza, malaria or even cigarette smoking. He's talking about people drinking fizzy drinks in North America. The guy is either ignorant or insane or a liar. This one statement is enough to discredit him and yet he has made another video in which he says: "Fructose is ethanol without the buzz ... fructose is poison." That video has had nearly two million hits on Youtube. It's over. The morons have won.

He's another UCSF chump and it's no surprise to find that he's friendly with the anti-smoking loons of that quasi-university. In that same video, he refers to "the UCSF Legacy Tobacco Documents Library that Stan Glantz runs right across the street. Stan's a good guy. I like Stan a lot." Right there we have another disagreement because Stan is not a good guy. On the contrary, he is a charlatan and a crank and he should be investigated, prosecuted and imprisoned. He is another obsessive fruitcake who has found a pulpit from which to preach his warped, scientifically illiterate ideas thanks to the lax admissions standards of UCSF.

As you may know, Glantz regularly appears on television claiming that half of all teenage smokers picked up the habit solely as a result of seeing smoking in movies. This is a man who should, as Christopher Hitchens might have said, be out in the street, shouting and hollering with a cardboard sign around his neck and selling pencils from a cup. Do interviewers call him on his bampot theories? They do not. Instead he is perched up in San Francisco with millions of dollars of grants and a professorship in a subject which he has not studied at degree level and of which he apparently knows nothing.

Glantz also invented the heart miracle scam. What better illustration of the Western world's plunge into unreason can there be than this? Here we see the perils of the campaigner-researcher, the corruption of peer-review and the pitiful credulity of the media in perfect alignment.

To take just one example, last year Michael Siegel wrote about a heart miracle in one Minnesota county. It was so pathetic I don't think I even mentioned it at the time. In summary, some devious anti-smoking lobbyists cherry-picked a county and claimed that heart attacks had fallen by 45% after the smoking ban. Siegel listed some of the news stories that unquestioningly covered it.

For example, the headline of an ABC News article reads: "Smoking ban cuts cardiac events 45%, Mayo Clinic says."

A Procor headline reads: "Smoking ban cuts heart attacks in half."

A Thirdage.com article headline reads: "Smoking Ban Cuts Heart Attack Risk In Half."

The UPI headline about the research reads: "Smoking ban cut heart attacks risk in half."

The Minneapolis Star-Tribune headline reads: "Smoking bans cut cardiac events 45%."

The EMax Health headline is: "Smoking bans reduce heart attack rates by half, finds study."

The Business Insider headline reads: "Heart Attacks Decreased By 50% After These Workplaces Launched Smoking Bans."

The trick was a simple one. They didn't look at the year of the ban (2007). Instead they compared heart attack rates in 2001 with those of 2008. Sure enough, they fell by 45%, but this was not out of line with the general decline in heart attacks across the USA. The heart attack rate is falling everywhere. You may recall from last week that the UK saw a halving of heart attacks in the same decade. The longer the timeframe the bigger the fall. Cherry-pick one small county (population 150,000) and the effect can be exaggerated further.

This is routine deception on the part of tobacco control, but that is not the point. My point is that you don't need to be privy to this information to work out that "Smoking ban cut heart attacks risk in half" is a bullshit headline. You do not need to be well versed in statistics to work out that, if this were true, half of all heart attacks before the ban were caused by wafts of tobacco smoke in bars and restaurants. And you don't need to be cognisant of medical science to realise that this is simply preposterous.

Similarly, you do you need to understand biology to know that you are not going to get cancer from smelling tobacco on someone's shirt and yet the concept of thirdhand smoke has been widely talked about, not least by the Daily Mail, as if it was anything other than the ramblings of the insane.

Who came up with the idea of thirdhand smoke? Georg Matt. Who's Georg Matt? He's a wacky psychologist based in San Diego. There is a running theme here, is there not?

Where does every crackpot idea come from?

Where does every hysteria-driven, junk science-based ban begin?

Which is the home to the world's worst university?

Which state is dragging the world into an intellectual dark age?

California.

Lex Luther had the right idea. Bill Hicks had the right idea.

California has to go.






Monday, 11 January 2010

Still no heart attack miracle in England


Today, Michael Siegel dissects another junk science study purporting to show that the introduction of a smoking ban led to a drop in heart attacks. And so it goes on in the world of tobacco control. 

Back in the real world, recently published NHS figures have shown us that, just as there was no big drop in heart attack admissions in the first year of England's smoking ban, so there was no drop in the second year of the ban.

This graph shows the number of emergency admissions for acute myocardial infarction (heart attacks) in English hospitals from April 1998 to March 2009:




Ho-hum. It's the same old story. The rate was falling gradually before the ban and it has fallen just as gradually since the ban. 

Whenever hospital data is publicly available, there is no sign of a heart miracle. Whenever the raw data is available only to a select group of epidemiologists, there is a 'dramatic' drop in heart attacks. When an epidemiologist announces a drop in heart attacks in a small town or region, it gets global news coverage. When evidence from an entire nation shows that a smoking ban had no effect on heart attacks, the news is confined to a handful of blogs.

The story is always the same, and I apologise for boring readers with one null study after another. But spare a thought for Dr Anna Gilmore, whose job it is to turn this mundane data into a newsworthy study showing that the smoking ban has saved thousands of lives. She may be working on it at this very moment. 

At some point this year, the media will be reporting a heart miracle in England, based on the very evidence I have shown above (or carefully selected parts of it). It sounds incredible, Orwellian even, but it will happen, and when it does none of the real figures will matter. None of the data carefully collected around the country and displayed on the HES England website will matter. The number of people who really got rushed to hospital with a heart attack in those years will be irrelevant.

If you want chapter and verse, I can tell you that the heart attack rate dropped by 3.84% and 3.79% before the ban, and by 3.75% and 2.61% after the ban. These figures are nowhere near big enough to guarantee news coverage. When the study appears it will probably show that heart attacks fell by at least 10%. We know this because that's what was reported before the study even began.

We live in post-evidential times. Whatever he who pays the fiddler wants to believe happened, is what happened. The real events are of no consequence. They are trees falling in an empty forest.