Saturday 25 August 2012

That GCSE scandal in full

A typical schoolgirl awaits her GCSE results.
(Picture courtesy of the Daily Telegraph)

The teaching profession has gone into hysterics about so-called 'grade fixing' in this year's GCSE results. British readers will be familiar with the annual farce of semi-literate teenagers celebrating ever-improving exam results. Everybody knows that GCSEs, like A-Levels, have been systematically dumbed-down for political reasons and only the teaching unions seriously suggest otherwise. Last week—for the first time in 24 years (which is to say, ever since GCSEs were created)—records failed to be broken.

The teachers' response has been absolutely mind-boggling. Without a hint of irony, they have suggested that the rigour of examinations has been altered for political ends. They seem to genuinely believe that each new batch of pupils has a legal right to be awarded better exam results than any generation in history and they are prepared to sue the government on the basis of equality legislation.

The Association of School and College Leaders (ASCL) says it may take legal action against exam boards over grading reforms which appear to have denied thousands a C grade in the core exam.

Malcolm Trobe, of the ASCL, which represents most secondary head teachers, said it was currently gathering information on the situation at schools where there were large numbers of pupils on the boundary between a C and D grade.

"We're examining whether this is hitting any particular groups of young people that are covered by the equal opportunities legislation," he said.

"We are not afraid of taking legal action if that is the appropriate step."

Words fail me.

A statement on the Leeds City Council website by Councillor Judith Blake said: "We do not feel this basic principle of fairness has been adhered to in this case and will be looking with colleagues nationally at the possibility of raising a legal challenge to ensure Ofqual and the government put this right."

Quite extraordinary.

Labour called for the Commons education select committee to conduct an official inquiry into the affair and the Welsh Assembly Government launched its own probe.

Good God almighty. Let's look at the facts for a second. The graph below shows the last ten years of GCSE results. Since 2003, the number of A-C grades (de facto passes in an age in which no one is allowed to fail) has risen from 58.1% to 69.4%. The proportion of As and A*s rose from 17.4% to 22.4%.

The alleged scandal of tougher marking led to the class of 2012 doing very slightly worse than the class of 2011, but there were still more A-Cs dished out than in any year prior to 2011 and more As and A*s awarded than in any year prior to 2010.

So, if this year's pupils have a legal right to have their exam results upgraded on the basis of "fairness" and "equality", it seems to me that everybody who took GCSEs between 1988 and 2009 should also raise a "legal challenge". I passed mine in 1992 and I demand an enquiry.


dognamedblue said...

I took mine in 1983 [the death by nuclear holocaust year ;] & even though you had to get at least 40% to get a grade C o level I've always thought I was one of the last generations before they started their long road of dumbing down. mind you even though I've got 13 of them I've never needed one of them to get a job ever, some might say even back then they were a waste of time

UKYoungVote said...

Do your research before you start talking. Too many just shoot from the hip without knowing what they are talking about. The complaints by teachers and local authorities are not about grades being lower then last year but that they were 'fixed' to be lower for some, not all students. And sone students had results that were previously awarded downgraded.

PJH said...

"So, if this year's pupils have a legal right to have their exam results upgraded on the basis of "fairness" and "equality", it seems to me that everybody who took GCSEs between 1988 and 2009 should also raise a "legal challenge". I passed mine in 1992 and I demand an enquiry."

First year intake for GCSE's here (except maths, which I was forced to take a year early and get an O Level instead.)

Think I could get away with demanding an enquiry as well?

Though as Dog said above - none of the 4 jobs I've had since have never taken the slightest interest in either what subjects I took or the fact I got an F in some of them. I hated French.

A-level results likewise; I got a B and 2 C's. Which got me into Uni some years later; I started, but stopped after the first term, a 4th A level; Couldn't cope because 4 A levels took up all the alloted periods on the timetable - HTF do teens get 5+ A levels these days??

(8x5 periods meant the usual (to everyone else in the 6th form) 3 A levels got you 10 free periods to 'do work' - which got consumed by my 4th A level.)

PJH said...
This comment has been removed by the author.